The quick version
Prepare eight question cards. Everyone secretly writes a number on their arrow. Starting with the star holder, place arrows answer-side down into an estimated low-to-high row. Only the first player may reposition their own arrow afterward. Reveal; remove as few arrows as needed to leave an increasing row, with equal numbers allowed. Score one per remaining arrow. Pass the star left and finish after eight questions.
Saved on this device only — clearing your browser's cache or site data removes them (no account backup).
Prepare eight comfortable questions
Give each of 4–8 players an arrow and matching marker. Write your name on the name side. Shuffle eight question cards into a face-down round pile and choose a starting player to hold the star. Keep the remaining questions available for replacements.
Read each question before anyone answers. Agree its unit and any printed numerical range. Anyone may request a replacement with no explanation; take a fresh card and still play eight completed questions. This is a guessing game about chosen answers, not a demand for sensitive disclosures.
Place your own answer
Everyone writes a numerical answer privately on their arrow’s blank side. Follow the card’s unit or 0–100 scale. Do not give verbal hints or react to others in a way that reveals your value. The starting player lays their arrow answer-side down.
Going clockwise, each person inserts their own arrow below, above or between the arrows already placed. Leave every other arrow where it is. After all are placed, the starter alone may move their own arrow once to any position, or leave it in place.
Reveal in low-to-high order. Keep the longest possible row whose numbers never decrease, removing other arrows. Equal values may stay together. For example, 10, 40, 25, 60 loses either 40 or 25 and scores three; it does not lose both. If several choices keep the same maximum number, choose any of them.
Score one point for each retained arrow and add it to the star. Erase answers and pass the star clockwise. After eight questions, the group’s total is the result, with a maximum of eight times the number of people. There are no individual winners. Compare only sessions with the same group size and format.
Make the reveal a conversation
Allow a short optional explanation after scoring, then move on. A surprising answer is not an error; only a misunderstood unit or an accidentally exposed answer warrants replacing the question. In that case erase all answers and restart with a new question, adding no points for the discarded attempt.
Already know the game?
Ideas & Twists
Choose a variation together before you start.
Fun Facts · See main rules
House suggestionEveryday estimates
Use eight original numerical questions about ordinary preferences, such as ideal number of plants in a room or preferred walk length in minutes. State the unit before writing. Avoid private finances, health and personal rankings. All placement and scoring rules stay the same.
Fun Facts · See main rules
House suggestionFictional answers
Each person chooses a fictional character known to everyone and announces it before the game. Answer all eight questions as that character, making a best guess rather than researching canon. People may explain their interpretation only after reveal. Score normally.
Fun Facts · See main rules
House suggestionNo starter correction
After the final arrow is placed, reveal immediately. The starter cannot move their arrow. This makes the first placement a commitment; rotate the star and keep the usual eight-question score.
Fun Facts · See main rules
House suggestionAnonymous order
Add identical folded paper slips. Everyone writes their number inside one slip, then mix the slips without looking. Open them one at a time and work together to match each revealed number to a named arrow before revealing that arrow. Score one correct match per person over eight questions. This replaces numerical ordering with identity matching; ties count if the actual numbers agree.
About this guide
Base play follows Repos Production’s eight-question rules, including starter-only movement and equal answers. The example, comfortable-question procedure and five variations are original hosting suggestions. A visible discussion comment supports investigating the game; a removed opening post is not treated as evidence.
Ready for something different?
Find another game →