The quick version
Secretly deal one blue fish and red fish to everyone except the guesser. Show all fish players the answer, then hear one answer each. The guesser flips suspected red fish one at a time and may stop to bank points. Flipping blue loses all guesser points for that round. Score both guesses and surviving bluffs, rotate the guesser and finish after equal turns.
Saved on this device only — clearing your browser's cache or site data removes them (no account backup).
One truth among the bluffs
Choose a guesser and give each other player a face-down fish: exactly one blue, all others red. Each privately checks their color. Hold the question card so the guesser sees only the question while everybody else sees the answer. Replace a question the guesser already knows before hearing answers.
Read the question and allow about 15 seconds to think. Red players invent wrong answers; blue must use the printed correct answer. Go clockwise for one answer each. Keep the same delivery opportunity for everyone and do not show fish colors until selected.
Stop before the true answer catches you
The guesser chooses a player whose answer seems false and flips that fish. A red fish adds 1 provisional point. The guesser may then stop and keep accumulated points or flip another fish. Clearing every red while leaving blue earns 1 extra point. Flipping blue ends the round and gives the guesser zero.
Score the fish players too. Each unflipped red earns 1 point per fish that was flipped, including blue if it was selected. A flipped red scores zero. Blue scores only when flipped, earning 1 point for every fish still unflipped. If blue remains hidden, blue scores zero.
For example, with four fish, flipping two reds and stopping gives the guesser 2, the remaining red 2 and blue zero. Flipping blue next instead gives the guesser zero, the remaining red 3 and blue 1. Previously flipped reds score zero in both cases.
Pass the guesser role clockwise and redeal fish every round. With four or five people, everyone guesses twice; with six to ten, everyone guesses once. Highest total wins, and this guide shares tied wins.
Keep fake answers fresh
If the printed answer is accidentally shown to the guesser, replace the card and redeal fish without scoring. Set completed questions aside; their surprise is reduced once everyone knows the answer. Give first-time bluffers an extra unscored practice question before beginning the equal-turn game.
Already know the game?
Ideas & Twists
Choose a variation together before you start.
Sounds Fishy · See main rules
House suggestionThirty-second invention
Give fish players 30 seconds instead of 15 to think before answers begin. Keep ordinary elimination, points and equal turns.
Sounds Fishy · See main rules
House suggestionOne-sentence answer
Each fish player gives only one sentence with no follow-up explanation. The blue answer must still faithfully communicate the printed fact. The guesser cannot ask clarifying questions afterward.
Sounds Fishy · See main rules
House suggestionWritten answers first
Give all fish players paper. Before anybody speaks, everyone writes their answer and commits to it. Then read clockwise. This prevents later red answers from adapting to earlier bluffs; score normally.
Sounds Fishy · See main rules
House suggestionOne explanation request
After hearing all answers, the guesser may ask exactly one player to explain their answer in one additional sentence. That player must keep the same answer. Then begin normal flips and banking.
Sounds Fishy · See main rules
House suggestionOne circuit for everyone
With four or five players, shorten the game to one guesser turn each. Keep all other rules and score both roles as usual. With larger groups this is already the standard endpoint, so it changes nothing there.
About this guide
Physical role and guesser mechanics are publisher-confirmed; detailed scoring and player-count endpoint were checked in the linked rules explanation. All twists and the exact-score teaching example are original. Shared ties are a house convention.
Ready for something different?
Find another game →