1 Samuel 17:55–17:58, King James Version
Italic words were supplied in the English translation for clarity.
1 Samuel 17:55–17:58
Saul asks whose son David is
Saul watches the fight and still has to ask whose son this is
When Saul saw David go forth against the Philistine, he asked Abner, the captain of the host, whose son the youth is. Abner said, As thy soul liveth, O king, I cannot tell. The king tells him to inquire. After the killing, David is brought with the Philistine's head in his hand.
The question collides with chapter 16, where Saul already sent to Jesse and loved David as armourbearer. Source, role, and literary explanations all remain live. The unit does not let a tidy harmony erase the difficulty.
David answers with Jesse's name while carrying a severed head
Saul asks, Whose son art thou, thou young man? David answers, I am the son of thy servant Jesse the Bethlehemite. Lineage, not a speech about the stone, is what the king receives in this closing.
The recognition puzzle is not proof that David has been deceiving anyone, and it is not a riddle later readers must solve before they can hear the answer he actually gives.
How this should shape us
Let a hard seam in a book stay hard. Do not invent a biography to protect the story's smoothness, and do not use uncertainty as a charge against the youth holding the head.
Teach it back
Explain 1 Samuel 17:55–17:58 in your own words, including its movement, one source-controlled detail, one uncertainty, one affected person, and one misuse the context rules out.
Your explanation stays in this browser. It is not sent or saved.
Go deeper
The explanation above is meant to stand on its own. Open these notes only if you want language, history, disagreements, or source locations.
Where careful interpreters disagreeThe strongest options and their difficulties
Where do careful readers disagree?
Best judgment: This inquiry conflicts at face value with chapter 16's court relationship; source, role-recognition, patronymic, and literary explanations remain competing readings.
How certain? probableResearch trail and exact locationsThe source record behind this section
Supports: Exact displayed KJV words, verse order, paragraph metadata, supplied-word markup, and complete unit coverage.
1 Samuel 17:55–17:58, pinned eng-kjv2006 USFM-derived repository corpus
Supports: Masoretic Hebrew wording and morphology, with the two KJV-Hebrew versification shifts stated rather than silently offset.
Open Scriptures MorphHB v2.2, commit 6a5db284c715c18b239422e57bb89684e6a19f00, wlc/1Sam.xml, OSIS 17:55–17:58; KJV 20:42 spans Hebrew 20:42–21:1, KJV 21:1–15 maps to Hebrew 21:2–16, KJV 23:29 maps to Hebrew 24:1, and KJV 24:1–22 maps to Hebrew 24:2–23
Supports: Only the translator notes actually printed for these verses, used for lexical, grammatical, textual, historical, and older-English controls.
NET Bible First Edition Notes, 1 Samuel PDF, printed pp. 504–543, exact tc/tn/sn entries attached to 17:55–17:58
Supports: Material Qumran-Samuel evidence and witness relationships, not a complete apparatus or automatic preference for one text.
Tov, 'The Textual Affiliations of 4QSama,' JSOT 14 (1979), pp. 37–53, with 4QSama readings checked only where a unit names them
Supports: Abstract-supported importance of the Septuagint for 1 Samuel and methodological caution about textual plurality; no unchecked verse reconstruction.
Aejmelaeus, Oxford Handbook of Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (2025), pp. 191–212, official abstract and §10.4 publisher metadata on 1 Samuel
Supports: One relatively early integrated/two-edition account of composition, structure, and historiographic value, retained as a contested model.
Garsiel, JHS 10.5 (2010), pp. 1–42, named structural or composition discussion covering the movement that includes 1 Samuel 17:55–17:58
Supports: Only the publisher-visible book architecture and theological scope; the paywalled body is not treated as inspected.
Goldingay, The Theology of the Book of Samuel (2024), official frontmatter and TOC: 1 Samuel 13:1–20:42[21:1], pp. 77–110
Sources for This Section
These records identify the source, the claim it supports, and the exact location used. A source remains evidence to evaluate; it does not replace the biblical text.
Biblical text
King James (Authorized) Version — eng-kjv2006
eBible.org and CrossWire Bible Society
USFM archive eng-kjv2006_usfm.zip; source files dated 2026-08-19; downloaded 2026-08-24; archive SHA-256 aec1b3b26c622fd3d963d2bbac963016b9513246ffbfa20da00bb100372ea007; normalized corpus SHA-256 09aef51d90488aa7b9722b3fd9a93f4b25f6bf2064c5fd798fb39673c300ddf2.
Supports: Exact displayed KJV words, verse order, paragraph metadata, supplied-word markup, and complete unit coverage.
Exact location: 1 Samuel 17:55–17:58, pinned eng-kjv2006 USFM-derived repository corpus
Open source ↗hebrew text and morphology
Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible: 1 Samuel
Open Scriptures
Open Scriptures, release 2.2
Supports: Masoretic Hebrew wording and morphology, with the two KJV-Hebrew versification shifts stated rather than silently offset.
Exact location: Open Scriptures MorphHB v2.2, commit 6a5db284c715c18b239422e57bb89684e6a19f00, wlc/1Sam.xml, OSIS 17:55–17:58; KJV 20:42 spans Hebrew 20:42–21:1, KJV 21:1–15 maps to Hebrew 21:2–16, KJV 23:29 maps to Hebrew 24:1, and KJV 24:1–22 maps to Hebrew 24:2–23
Open source ↗translation and translator notes
NET Bible First Edition Notes: 1 Samuel
Biblical Studies Press
Biblical Studies Press, 2006
Supports: Only the translator notes actually printed for these verses, used for lexical, grammatical, textual, historical, and older-English controls.
Exact location: NET Bible First Edition Notes, 1 Samuel PDF, printed pp. 504–543, exact tc/tn/sn entries attached to 17:55–17:58
Open source ↗peer reviewed scholarly article
The Textual Affiliations of 4QSama
Emanuel Tov
Journal for the Study of the Old Testament 14, 1979
Supports: Material Qumran-Samuel evidence and witness relationships, not a complete apparatus or automatic preference for one text.
Exact location: Tov, 'The Textual Affiliations of 4QSama,' JSOT 14 (1979), pp. 37–53, with 4QSama readings checked only where a unit names them
Open source ↗scholarly handbook chapter abstract and metadata
The Significance of the Septuagint in the Textual Study of the Hebrew Bible
Anneli Aejmelaeus
The Oxford Handbook of Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, 2025
Supports: Abstract-supported importance of the Septuagint for 1 Samuel and methodological caution about textual plurality; no unchecked verse reconstruction.
Exact location: Aejmelaeus, Oxford Handbook of Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (2025), pp. 191–212, official abstract and §10.4 publisher metadata on 1 Samuel
Open source ↗peer reviewed open access scholarly article
The Book of Samuel: Its Composition, Structure and Significance as a Historiographical Source
Moshe Garsiel
The Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 10.5, 2010
Supports: One relatively early integrated/two-edition account of composition, structure, and historiographic value, retained as a contested model.
Exact location: Garsiel, JHS 10.5 (2010), pp. 1–42, named structural or composition discussion covering the movement that includes 1 Samuel 17:55–17:58
Open source ↗scholarly monograph frontmatter and table of contents
The Theology of the Book of Samuel
John Goldingay
Cambridge University Press, 2024
Supports: Only the publisher-visible book architecture and theological scope; the paywalled body is not treated as inspected.
Exact location: Goldingay, The Theology of the Book of Samuel (2024), official frontmatter and TOC: 1 Samuel 13:1–20:42[21:1], pp. 77–110
Open source ↗